OK so I have never scouted for my opponent except for pressing the scout button. No, I'm not embarrassed. So I just noticed that I cannot watch any past games? Is there a work around for this?

I'm able to.

I just tested and I could watch a random game not involving my team from about 10 weeks ago

Wow. Something is not right then.

Go to League Home Screen. Then Look at this week's schedule. Above that; there should be a "View All" button. Click it. You should see a complete season schedule: Games played & games yet to be played. There are three icons next to each game played. The first is Film (watch the game). The second is Play Log (every play for each team & result of play). The third is Stats (self explanatory). Hope this helps. :)

Thanks! You think I would have seen that earlier.