A curious thing happened. I made an extension offer to two players. I didn't change the numbers they asked for except to reduce the number of years. However, they both rejected the offers.

Is that working as expected?

If you reduce the # of years, you are effectively reducing the bonus amount they are asking for which will cause them to reject the offer. If you modified the bonus to match what they originally asked for then they should accept it

I put a ticket in to give feedback when this happens and the offer would be immediately rejected. The renegotiations are pretty straightforward of whether the player will accept it or not, so the system will know whether the request will be accepted when it's submitted instead of having to wait for the sim to reject it.

Oh, you mean like "your offer is too ____"? Cool.

Exactly.