People who liked this post

  • Community
  • Log In
Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
General MFN Discussion
  • ‹
  • 1
  • 2
  • ›
Gustoon
Re: Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
by Gustoon @ 1/22/2015 10:12 am
Thank you. I don't know if anyone agrees but I don't really need the player # just position , which is helpful.
Cheers
WarEagle
Re: Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
by WarEagle @ 1/22/2015 12:16 pm
Gustoon wrote:
Thank you. I don't know if anyone agrees but I don't really need the player # just position , which is helpful.
Cheers

I like both. There are a lot of names duplicated from league to league, or nearly duplicated. In one league, I have two WR both named J Thomas (or something similar). I get confused about who is who.
martinwarnett
Re: Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
by martinwarnett @ 1/22/2015 4:54 pm
jdavidbakr wrote:
Gustoon wrote:
To add to this wishlist...
Would it be possible on replays to have the player position in please? eg: "CB John Smith tackles RB Smith Johnson....."

Cheers

That's not a bad idea - I'll put it on the list.

To caveat that, can you have the position on the field rather than the player positions? It would make more sense if you've say a 3rd string FS playing as SS for a few plays?

Or would that be too confusing?
jdavidbakr
Re: Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
by jdavidbakr (Site Admin) @ 1/22/2015 4:58 pm
martinwarnett wrote:
To caveat that, can you have the position on the field rather than the player positions? It would make more sense if you've say a 3rd string FS playing as SS for a few plays?

Or would that be too confusing?

Good question - I was thinking the player's assigned position but knowing what position they were on for the play would help in game planning - possibly if they are playing out of position doing something similar to how the player search results display that (i.e, a player is the 3rd string FS playing as SS for the play the play-by-play would say "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (SS)" or "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (as SS)" vs. if he was in his position "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith"

Thoughts?
martinwarnett
Re: Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
by martinwarnett @ 1/22/2015 5:56 pm
jdavidbakr wrote:
martinwarnett wrote:
To caveat that, can you have the position on the field rather than the player positions? It would make more sense if you've say a 3rd string FS playing as SS for a few plays?

Or would that be too confusing?

Good question - I was thinking the player's assigned position but knowing what position they were on for the play would help in game planning - possibly if they are playing out of position doing something similar to how the player search results display that (i.e, a player is the 3rd string FS playing as SS for the play the play-by-play would say "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (SS)" or "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (as SS)" vs. if he was in his position "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith"

Thoughts?

Personally, I'd say "24-FS Joe Smith (as SS)" reads a bit wordy. "24-SS Joe Smith" would obviously be shorter and readable, but then people would think "Hmm, he's a FS". I always find I come up with suggestions that sound reasonable and have numerous implementation details ;)
Gustoon
Re: Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
by Gustoon @ 1/23/2015 10:14 am
Yikes...another request.

In the Offensive plays tab, you can filter personnel, but there is no mention of FB players, (even they are in the playbook).
There are 1 RB, 2 RB and even 3RB formations, one of which probably includes the FB, but it isn't clear.
WarEagle
Re: Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
by WarEagle @ 1/23/2015 11:08 am
jdavidbakr wrote:


Good question - I was thinking the player's assigned position but knowing what position they were on for the play would help in game planning - possibly if they are playing out of position doing something similar to how the player search results display that (i.e, a player is the 3rd string FS playing as SS for the play the play-by-play would say "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (SS)" or "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (as SS)" vs. if he was in his position "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith"

Thoughts?

I like "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (as SS)".
WarEagle
Re: Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
by WarEagle @ 1/23/2015 11:09 am
Gustoon wrote:
Yikes...another request.

In the Offensive plays tab, you can filter personnel, but there is no mention of FB players, (even they are in the playbook).
There are 1 RB, 2 RB and even 3RB formations, one of which probably includes the FB, but it isn't clear.

The FB is considered a RB in the play filters.
Gustoon
Re: Wishlist - Player Card "Stats" tab
by Gustoon @ 1/23/2015 11:10 am
WarEagle wrote:
jdavidbakr wrote:


Good question - I was thinking the player's assigned position but knowing what position they were on for the play would help in game planning - possibly if they are playing out of position doing something similar to how the player search results display that (i.e, a player is the 3rd string FS playing as SS for the play the play-by-play would say "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (SS)" or "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (as SS)" vs. if he was in his position "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith"

Thoughts?

I like "Tackle by 24-FS Joe Smith (SS)".

That works
  • ‹
  • 1
  • 2
  • ›
Copyright ©2013-2026 Catalyst Productions | Weather data powered by Visual Crossing
Website Version ca52262
Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy