It's preseason week 3 in the Football Moguls league.

I have two kickers, both assigned to the depth chart.

In the game sim, I had it set for backups to take over in the 4th Q. Instead of my backup K, coming in, my backup C, (originally a RT), is attempting kicks instead.

Here's one of his "attempts".
https://moguls.myfootballnow.com/watch/1366#304679

When you set your kickers as you did, one doing kickoffs as the starter and one doing field goals/extra points as the starter, the logic pulls both of them cause they are starters. Leaving a non kicker to be selected by the AI.

Just have one slotted in both spots as the #1 and the other guy slotted as both #2s . Generally this only happens in preseason or if you pull guys due to a large lead.

OK...

That makes sense.

Thanks