Per the NFL Rulebook:


It sure would be nice to prevent an onside kicking team from continuing to try until they succeed. That's super annoying.

Thats my understanding also, although in NCAA Team R can have 5 yards enforced from the succeeding spot (OOB spot in this case).

Again, I've not see this happen in MFN, if it does, then it needs addressing imo.

i think best thing is wait until you see something like this happening MFN before you go posting a suggestion thread though that is my 2 cents nothing more or less

Punisher, LMAO. I did not post the OP, nor did I make a thread on this...I am merely stating that I have not seen this happen in MFN (wrongful enforcement in a game on onsides kicks)....one can be thorough in his wherewithal.

I also went on to say that if this does happen, it should be corrected!!!

It is a genuine pity your teams do not reflect your competitive activeness on the forums.

i know you didnt post this i was just saying that to the OP

I've seen it happen more than once. It is an annoyance. It doesn't happen often, but it does happen. Cost me a game, too.

Needs correcting then imho.

I shouldn't have made two threads about this. One was too many. I will be continuing this discussion (and then finally ending my part of it) in the "Allow receiving teams to take possession of illegal onside kicks" thread.